Walking into Angelo Brocato’s in New Orleans feels like stepping through a portal to Sicily circa 1905. This treasured Italian ice cream parlor has maintained authentic Sicilian traditions for over a century, becoming a cornerstone of New Orleans’ culinary landscape. Founded by Angelo Brocato, who mastered the art of Italian gelato as a 12-year-old apprentice in Palermo, this establishment began in the French Quarter before relocating to its current Mid-City address at 214 N. Carrollton Ave in the 1970s. The shop’s enduring presence offers a taste of authentic Italian confections that have delighted generations of New Orleanians and visitors alike.
15% OFF Sitewide!, Orders $50+
A Sicilian Dream in the Big Easy
Angelo Brocato’s journey began in humble circumstances but was fueled by extraordinary passion. After learning the craft in Sicily, Brocato immigrated to America in the early 1900s, bringing with him centuries-old Italian dessert recipes. New Orleans, with its existing Italian community, provided fertile ground for his culinary dreams. When he opened his doors in 1905, he introduced authentic Sicilian flavors that were relatively unknown in Louisiana at the time.
The original location in the French Quarter quickly became a neighborhood fixture, with locals lining up for a taste of the old country. Brocato’s commitment to traditional methods and high-quality ingredients set his shop apart from the beginning. The family business passed down through generations, with each new steward maintaining the founder’s dedication to authenticity while gradually expanding their offerings.
The move to Mid-City in the 1970s marked a new chapter, allowing the shop to grow while maintaining its old-world charm. Today’s patrons enter through the same classic storefront with its iconic green and white awning, stepping into an interior that features marble countertops and vintage fixtures. This meticulous preservation of ambiance transports visitors to another time and place, creating an experience that goes beyond the desserts themselves.
I’ve found that food-themed apparel celebrating places like Angelo Brocato can be a fun way to show appreciation for these culinary landmarks. The shop’s current owners, direct descendants of Angelo himself, continue to operate the business with the same principles that guided their ancestor over a century ago.
Authentic Italian Delicacies That Transport You to Sicily
The heart of Angelo Brocato’s appeal lies in its expansive menu of traditional Italian frozen treats and pastries. Their gelato, made in small batches using methods virtually unchanged since the shop’s founding, features distinctive flavors that can be hard to find elsewhere in the United States. The signature torroncino combines vanilla with cinnamon and almonds for a uniquely fragrant experience, while their spumoni layers chocolate, vanilla, and pistachio with candied fruits and nuts.
Cassata, another standout flavor, draws inspiration from the traditional Sicilian cake of the same name, incorporating candied citrus, chocolate, and a hint of liqueur. During Carnival season, they even offer a special King Cake gelato that pays homage to New Orleans traditions while maintaining Italian techniques. The creativity shown in these offerings demonstrates how Angelo Brocato has balanced preservation with innovation over decades.
Beyond frozen delights, the pastry case showcases an equally impressive array of authentic Italian dessert recipes. Their cannoli—crisp shells filled with sweetened ricotta and often dotted with chocolate chips or candied fruit—are frequently cited as the finest in the city. The delicate sfogliatelle features dozens of paper-thin layers forming a shell around a citrusy semolina filling, while rum babas soak in a sweet syrup that makes them irresistibly moist.
The cookie selection rounds out their offerings with varieties that reflect different Italian regions and traditions:
- Cuccidati – Fig-filled cookies traditionally served during Christmas
- Pignoli – Chewy almond cookies topped with pine nuts
- Rainbow cookies – Colorful almond layers with chocolate coating
- Biscotti Regina – Sesame-coated cookies with a satisfying crunch
- Ricotta cookies – Soft, cake-like treats with a hint of citrus
Weathering Storms: A Century of Resilience
Angelo Brocato’s history parallels many of the challenges faced by New Orleans itself, demonstrating remarkable resilience through major historical events. The shop survived the Great Depression when many luxury items became unaffordable for average Americans. During World War II, despite rationing and supply chain difficulties, the family found ways to continue operations, albeit with adapted recipes and offerings.
Perhaps no challenge tested the shop’s staying power more than Hurricane Katrina in 2005. The devastating storm and subsequent flooding left the Mid-City neighborhood underwater, and Angelo Brocato suffered severe damage to its historic interior. Family members returned to find equipment destroyed and heirloom fixtures ruined. Many businesses in similar situations never reopened, but the Brocato family remained committed to restoring this piece of New Orleans history.
After extensive renovations and community support, the shop triumphantly reopened in 2006, becoming a symbol of New Orleans’ comeback spirit. Arthur Brocato, the current owner, has spoken about the emotional weight of that period and the determination required to rebuild. The shop’s survival and continued success reflect both family dedication and the deep cultural significance of Italian desserts in the city’s culinary landscape.
More recently, the COVID-19 pandemic presented yet another existential threat. Like many food establishments, Angelo Brocato had to adapt quickly, implementing takeout options and safety protocols while maintaining their commitment to quality. Their ability to navigate these challenges speaks to the shop’s adaptability—a quality as essential to longevity as their secret family recipes.
Recognition and Accolades: From Neighborhood Gem to National Treasure
After decades of quietly creating exceptional desserts, Angelo Brocato received national recognition when it was named a 2023 James Beard semifinalist in the outstanding bakery category. This prestigious acknowledgment placed the century-old shop alongside contemporary bakeries from across the country. Arthur Brocato expressed being “honored and humbled” by the nomination, which validated the family’s commitment to preserving authentic techniques and recipes.
Local recognition has been consistent throughout the shop’s history, with Angelo Brocato regularly winning “best of” awards in New Orleans publications. Many food critics and travel writers consider it the premier Italian bakery in Louisiana, praising both the quality of its offerings and its cultural significance. The establishment has been featured in numerous food documentaries and travel shows focusing on America’s historic eateries.
Beyond formal accolades, the shop’s true testament lies in its generational customer base. Grandparents who visited as children now bring their grandchildren, creating family traditions centered around Brocato’s treats. This connection to dessert traditions across generations speaks to something more meaningful than culinary success—it represents cultural continuity and shared experiences that define community identity.
I’ve noticed that establishments like Angelo Brocato inspire many home bakers to try creating homemade versions of their pastries. While nothing compares to the original, sharing recipes and techniques helps preserve these culinary traditions. If you’ve created your own version of an Italian classic, consider submitting it to our community of dessert enthusiasts.
Keeping Italian Traditions Alive in the Crescent City
Angelo Brocato serves as more than just a dessert destination—it functions as a cultural ambassador for Italian heritage in New Orleans. The shop plays a particularly significant role during St. Joseph’s Day celebrations, an important religious and cultural observance for the Italian-American community. Each March, they prepare special treats like zeppole di San Giuseppe (cream-filled pastries) and traditional Italian zeppole that are essential components of the holiday.
The shop hosts its own St. Joseph’s altar, continuing a tradition brought to New Orleans by Sicilian immigrants. These elaborately decorated food displays honor St. Joseph and serve as community gathering points. Brocato’s participation helps ensure that younger generations remain connected to these important cultural practices, even as the city’s demographics shift over time.
Beyond specific holidays, the shop serves as an everyday link to Italian culinary history. The methods used to create their signature items haven’t changed significantly in over a century, preserving techniques that might otherwise be lost to time. Staff members often share stories about the desserts’ origins with curious customers, acting as informal educators about Italian food traditions.
The shop’s expansion to include a smaller location at New Orleans International Airport (MSY) brings these authentic flavors to travelers, introducing the city’s Italian heritage to visitors from around the world. For locals, however, nothing compares to visiting the original Mid-City location, with its vintage atmosphere and full selection of treats. Angelo Brocato remains a perfect example of how food establishments can preserve cultural identity while becoming beloved institutions in their adopted communities.
If you know of a valuable local dessert shop like Angelo Brocato in your community, I encourage you to submit it to our business directory. These cultural treasures deserve recognition and support to ensure they continue delighting future generations with authentic flavors and traditions.