Jersey Shore bakeries and coffee shops have transformed beloved Girl Scout cookies into extraordinary desserts and drinks for the month of March 2025. These limited-edition treats reimagine classic flavors like Thin Mints, Samoas, and Tagalongs into creative confections that delight cookie fans while supporting a worthy cause. Local businesses throughout Monmouth and Ocean counties have partnered with the Girl Scouts of the Jersey Shore, which serves over 11,000 young members in the region. The collaborative effort combines community spirit with irresistible cookie-inspired indulgences that celebrate the annual Girl Scout cookie season in deliciously innovative ways.
Cookie Magic at Local Jersey Shore Eateries
March has become a month of delectable cookie-inspired creations across the Jersey Shore. Local establishments have embraced the challenge of transforming the iconic flavors that Girl Scout cookies are known for into specialty menu items that go beyond the box. The initiative not only satisfies cravings but also generates additional support for the Girl Scouts organization.
Broad Street Dough Co. has gone all-in with their cookie-themed doughnuts available at their locations in Oakhurst, Freehold, and Red Bank. Their signature Samoa doughnut perfectly captures the beloved cookie’s coconut and caramel notes, creating a ring-shaped masterpiece that honors the original while adding the pillowy comfort of a fresh doughnut. You can check out their full selection of creative offerings at broadstreetdoughco.com.
For ice cream enthusiasts, Hoffman’s Ice Cream has created a trio of Girl Scout cookie milkshakes that have customers lining up at their Point Pleasant Beach, Spring Lake Heights, Long Branch, and Little Silver locations. Priced at $8.75 for a generous 20 oz serving, these thick, creamy milkshakes come in Thin Mint, Samoa, and Tagalong varieties. The Thin Mint shake particularly shines with its refreshing mix of chocolate and mint that reminds me of my favorite cookies and cream recipe but with a minty twist.
Cupcakes and Coffee: More Ways to Enjoy Cookie Flavors
Cups and Cakes Bakery in Rumson has created a lineup of picture-perfect Girl Scout cookie cupcakes that look almost too good to eat. Each $4 cupcake captures the essence of Thin Mints, Samoas, or Tagalongs in cupcake form. The Tagalong cupcake features a peanut butter-filled center reminiscent of the rich peanut butter and chocolate combination that makes the original cookie so addictive.
For those needing a caffeine fix with their cookie cravings, Rook Coffee locations throughout Monmouth County are offering special Girl Scout cookie-inspired coffee drinks. Their Thin Mint cold brew has quickly become a customer favorite, blending the refreshing coolness of mint with rich chocolate notes in a perfectly balanced cold coffee that energizes while satisfying dessert cravings. The full menu of special offerings can be found on rookcoffee.com.
What makes these treats special is how they capture the essence of the original cookies while transforming them into entirely new experiences. The Samoa doughnut, for instance, doesn’t just mimic the flavor—it reinterprets it with a fresh, warm dough base that adds an exciting dimension to the familiar coconut-caramel profile. Similarly, the Thin Mint cold brew at Rook Coffee takes the cooling mint and chocolate combination and makes it refreshing in an entirely new way.
TopCookie Competition: Chefs Get Creative for a Cause
The excitement around Girl Scout cookie-inspired treats culminated in the TopCookie Competition held on March 6, 2024, across Monmouth and Ocean counties. This friendly culinary showdown featured local chefs competing to create the most innovative desserts using Girl Scout cookies as key ingredients. The event generated substantial buzz in the local food scene while raising funds for Girl Scout leadership programs.
Competing chefs displayed impressive creativity, transforming the cookies into elaborate desserts that maintained the essence of the original flavors while elevating them to restaurant-quality creations. Many entries incorporated multiple cookie varieties, creating complex flavor profiles that delighted judges and attendees alike. Some chefs even created savory applications, demonstrating just how versatile these cookies can be in the hands of culinary professionals.
The coveted awards included TopCookie Champion 2024 and the People’s Choice Award Winner, with fierce competition for both honors. Beyond the competitive aspect, the event created a festive atmosphere that celebrated both creative dessert innovation and community support. All proceeds from the competition went directly to supporting Girl Scouts of the Jersey Shore leadership programming, making it a win for both attendees’ taste buds and the organization’s mission.
Getting Your Hands on the Original Cookies
While the specialty treats are available throughout March 2025, many customers also want to purchase boxes of the original Girl Scout cookies that inspired them. Cookie sales continue through March, making it easy to compare the inspired creations with their source material. With 12 varieties available, including classics and new additions, there’s something for every cookie enthusiast.
Finding cookies to purchase is simple through multiple channels. Customers can buy in person at local booth sales, which can be located via girlscoutsjs.org/cookies, or order online through digitalcookie.girlscouts.org. The lineup includes traditional favorites along with the new online exclusive Raspberry Rally, which has quickly gained popularity among cookie collectors and enthusiasts.
Most varieties are priced at $5 per box, with specialty cookies available for $6 each. The pricing reflects both the quality ingredients and the program’s fundraising goals. For those looking to recreate some cookie magic at home, these boxes can also serve as inspiration for homemade versions like churro cheesecake cookies that capture that same blend of comfort and indulgence.
I’ve found that pairing the original cookies with the inspired treats offers a fun taste-testing experience. Trying a Thin Mint alongside Rook Coffee’s Thin Mint cold brew or comparing a Samoa with Broad Street Dough Co.’s Samoa doughnut provides a delightful flavor exploration that highlights both the original’s perfection and the creative interpretation.
Supporting Young Leaders One Treat at a Time
Every purchase, whether of original cookies or an inspired treat, contributes to valuable programming for the 11,000+ Girl Scouts in Monmouth and Ocean counties. The funds raised support leadership initiatives, community service projects, and skill-building activities that help shape the next generation of female leaders. While enjoying these limited-edition creations, customers can feel good knowing they’re supporting such a worthwhile cause.
The Girl Scouts of the Jersey Shore use cookie sale proceeds to fund a variety of programs that develop important life skills. From outdoor adventures to STEM education and community service, these diverse learning opportunities help girls develop confidence, character, and leadership abilities. The annual cookie program itself teaches valuable business skills like goal setting, decision making, money management, and interpersonal communication.
For those interested in learning more about how their purchases support local Girl Scouts, detailed information is available at jerseyshoregirlscouts.org. The site explains the impact of cookie sales and how funds are distributed to benefit troops and councils. As someone who loves both desserts and supporting good causes, I find the combination of innovative cookie creations and community support to be the perfect pairing.
Through this sweet collaboration between local businesses and Girl Scouts, the Jersey Shore community has created a win-win situation for everyone involved. Customers enjoy creative treats, local businesses gain exposure, and the Girl Scouts receive valuable funding for their programs. It’s a model of community partnership that serves both commercial interests and social good, all connected by everyone’s love for these iconic cookies and the values they represent.
If you’re in the Jersey Shore area this March, I highly recommend planning a cookie-inspired treat tour of these local establishments. The limited-time offerings provide a unique opportunity to experience familiar flavors transformed through local culinary talent while making a positive impact in your community. Whether you choose a doughnut, milkshake, cupcake, or coffee drink, you’ll be participating in a delicious tradition that goes beyond mere indulgence to support the development of tomorrow’s leaders.